The notion that only "superior philosophies" inevitably gain supporters assumes that good ideas always drive out bad. That's not how real-life marketplaces always work, and it's not how the marketplace of ideas always works, either. Remember what the markets for food and medication were like before the FDA?
Re: On the no-platforming of Nazis
I'm starting to speculate that democracies become especially vulnerable to fascism during a period when a new communications technology emerges. Hitler made very good use of film/video (it's a cliché that the film techniques Leni Riefenstahl pioneered are still being used today), and Trump is capitalizing off of reality TV and the Internet. I think it takes a generation or two for a society to develop a memetic immune response to the new information vector.